Offices

What the Mumbai desk actually buys

A family office that serves Indian money has a short list: the business, the house, a membership, and very little that needs a pitch deck.

By Aditi Rao, Contributing editor 4 minute read

A quiet study with an oak desk, a folded newspaper and a coffee cup
The useful meeting is the one in which most of the proposals leave with the people who brought them.

The office, in a building the family already owns, looks after one fortune. The principals are in the family. The analyst is paid to say no. Last year the no’s included a private-credit introduction, a second-home scheme in a country they like to holiday in, a ‘access vehicle’ for watches, and three decks that were the same deck with a different map of Africa on the cover. They declined all of them. What they kept was older: the operating company, a house in Mumbai and one outside it, a golf membership that is actually used, a jet card with a ceiling, and a small collection of pictures bought one at a time.

This is not a lack of ambition. It is a definition of the job. A family office is not a venture fund that shares a surname, and it is not a concierge. When someone arrives offering exclusive access to a boat, a club, or a diamond parcel ‘before the market’, the analyst asks who is being paid and in what order if the thing goes wrong. The answer is usually the end of the meeting. Readers who want the boat can charter the boat, as themselves, in the travel pages. Wrapping it in a structure does not make it an investment. It makes it a charter with a lawyer.

The jet card has a number of hours on it, reviewed every January, not a fantasy of ownership. The membership is one club. The art is hung, insured, and not required to beat the index. Cash and plain market funds cover the years in which the operating company should not be asked for a dividend. None of this will excite a dinner in Bandra. It will still be there after the dinner. That is the only test this desk applies, and it is the test CAWDN will apply when we write about offices in Lagos, Johannesburg and Singapore later. Excitement is a fee.

The purchases that are allowed to be fun

Fun is permitted. It is budgeted. A week on the water, a pair of guns if that is the family’s sport, a watch, a case of wine that will be drunk. These sit in a column labelled life, and they are not asked to appreciate. The moment a principal starts defending the yacht week as ‘networking’ or the picture as ‘inflation protection’, the analyst is supposed to say so. In this office she does. It is why she is still there. An office that needs every pleasure to be a thesis has already lost the distinction that keeps the fortune a fortune.

Children are the hard part, and not only in India. The next generation arrives with friends who have decks. The rule in this family is that a proposal from a friend is read last, not first, and that ‘everyone in the group is in’ is not a line in the memo. If the child wants a club, they use the club. If they want a business, it has customers who are not cousins. The office will not buy them an identity. Identity is unusually costly when it is purchased in a single season.

A list you can read aloud

If the holding cannot be explained without a password, a cousin, or a whisper, it does not belong on the sheet.

Nothing here is advice to copy a portfolio. It is a description of a refusal, which is what most good family offices actually do all day. CAWDN’s wealth section will keep describing refusals, because the India launch will be followed by a great many offers dressed as access. The Mumbai desk buys what it can use, insure, and explain. It charters the rest. That is not caution. It is how you still recognise your own fortune in December.

Further in the issue